Mobile Menu
Offshore Cases

Renova Resources Private Equity Limited -v- Gilbertson et al Cause No. FSD 61 of 2011-AJEF, Foster J., 26 October 2012

October 2012 Costs

CAYMAN ISLANDS

HIGH COURT (COMMERCIAL DIVISION)

COSTS - AWARD OF COSTS WHERE NEITHER PARTY WHOLLY SUCCESSFUL - INTERPRETATION OF GRAND COURT RULE (“GCR”) O.62

After judgment in the protracted and contentious litigation pertaining to the ownership of shares in Fabregé Limited, the parties returned to the Court with a number of sweep up issues, as well as a request for an order on costs. The Court took the view that there was no obvious event for the costs to follow: each party had victories and defeats on different issues over the four year battle. The Plaintiff had succeeded in establishing the Defendant’s breach of fiduciary duty, but failed to establish any consequential loss. Further, the Plaintiff’s improper conduct with respect to discovery was considered relevant to the issue of costs as blameworthy and culpable conduct entitled to be taken into account by the Court. As such, the overriding objective of GCR O.62 as set out in Rule 4(2): “that a successful party to any proceeding should recover from the opposing party the reasonable costs incurred by him in conducting the proceeding in an economical, expeditious and proper manner” was not applicable at all or should be departed from in the circumstances of the case. It was held that each party should therefore bear their own costs of the proceedings.

 

To continue reading full articles in PDF format:
Renova Resources Private Equity Limited -v- Gilbertson et al Cause No. FSD 61 of 2011-AJEF, Foster J., 26 October 2012

 

Accolades
_

"Few firms can come close to Conyers on one critical metric, and this is the breadth of the client base."
- IFLR1000

EDITOR & HEAD OF LITIGATION BERMUDA

Christian R. Luthi
Tel: +1 441 298 7814
Email: christian.luthi@conyersdill.com


Head of Litigation British virgin islands

Mark J. Forte
Tel: +1 284 852 1113
Email: mark.forte@conyersdill.com


Head of Litigation Cayman Islands

Paul Smith
Tel: +1 345 814 7777
Email: paul.smith@conyersdill.com


HEAD OF THE ASIA DISPUTES & RESTRUCTURING GROUP

Nigel K. Meeson, QC
Tel: +852 2842 9553
Email: nigel.meeson@conyersdill.com

Offshore Cases

Renova Resources Private Equity Limited -v- Gilbertson et al Cause No. FSD 61 of 2011-AJEF, Foster J., 26 October 2012

01 October 2012

CAYMAN ISLANDS

HIGH COURT (COMMERCIAL DIVISION)

COSTS - AWARD OF COSTS WHERE NEITHER PARTY WHOLLY SUCCESSFUL - INTERPRETATION OF GRAND COURT RULE (“GCR”) O.62

After judgment in the protracted and contentious litigation pertaining to the ownership of shares in Fabregé Limited, the parties returned to the Court with a number of sweep up issues, as well as a request for an order on costs. The Court took the view that there was no obvious event for the costs to follow: each party had victories and defeats on different issues over the four year battle. The Plaintiff had succeeded in establishing the Defendant’s breach of fiduciary duty, but failed to establish any consequential loss. Further, the Plaintiff’s improper conduct with respect to discovery was considered relevant to the issue of costs as blameworthy and culpable conduct entitled to be taken into account by the Court. As such, the overriding objective of GCR O.62 as set out in Rule 4(2): “that a successful party to any proceeding should recover from the opposing party the reasonable costs incurred by him in conducting the proceeding in an economical, expeditious and proper manner” was not applicable at all or should be departed from in the circumstances of the case. It was held that each party should therefore bear their own costs of the proceedings.

 

To continue reading full articles in PDF format:
Renova Resources Private Equity Limited -v- Gilbertson et al Cause No. FSD 61 of 2011-AJEF, Foster J., 26 October 2012

 

 

EDITOR & HEAD OF LITIGATION BERMUDA

Christian R. Luthi
Tel.: +1 441 298 7814
Email.: christian.luthi@conyersdill.com


Head of Litigation British virgin islands

Mark J. Forte
Tel.: +1 284 852 1113
Email.: mark.forte@conyersdill.com


Head of Litigation Cayman Islands

Paul Smith
Tel.: +1 345 814 7777
Email.: paul.smith@conyersdill.com


HEAD OF THE ASIA DISPUTES & RESTRUCTURING GROUP

Nigel K. Meeson, Q.C.
Tel.: +852 2842 9553
Email.: nigel.meeson@conyersdill.com